2025 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2025 Tesla Model Y
2025 Volkswagen ID.4 vs. 2025 Tesla Model Y
Which One is Right for You?
| Feature | VW ID.4 (Our choice!) |
Tesla Model Y |
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $39,735 | $43,990 |
| Engine Power | 335 hp | 384 hp |
| Range | 291 Miles | 337 miles |
| Warranty | 4-year/50,000-mile | 8 years/100,000 miles |
| View New VW ID.4 | View Used Inventory |
Overview
The Volkswagen ID.4 and the Tesla Model Y are popular electric crossovers. While both offer advanced technology and superb features, we at Crain Volkswagen of Fayetteville think the ID.4 is the overall better option. Keep reading to see why!
Features & Interior
Both the ID.4 and Model Y have wireless charging, touchscreen displays, and advanced safety features. They both also offer massaging seats. Inside, the ID.4 has a traditional layout that makes it easy to control. It also offers a soft leatherette and cloth upholstery that can comfortably seat five people. The Model Y has a third-row option, but the ID.4 focuses on a roomy, relaxed feel, which many people appreciate.
Driving & Performance
The ID.4 offers a smooth, steady ride with up to 335 horsepower. The AWD model can go from 0 to 60 mph in 4.9 seconds. While the Model Y accelerates faster, the ID.4 is all about providing a stable and comfortable drive on city streets and highways. If you prefer smooth driving over high-speed thrills, the ID.4 is the right fit.
Range & Charging
The ID.4 can travel up to 291 miles on a full charge, which is great for most trips. Volkswagen includes three years of free charging at Electrify America stations (up to 500 kWh), making charging on the go easy and affordable. You can also use an optional home charging cable for added convenience. The Model Y offers a bit more range, but the ID.4’s free charging makes it a good deal for those who want to save on charging costs.
Technology & Connectivity
The ID.4’s technology is simple and convenient. It has a large 12.9-inch touchscreen with buttons for climate controls. Unlike the Model Y, this infotainment system works with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The ID.4 also has VW’s Car-Net, which lets you control features like climate and other remote features. Plus, you get a free trial of SiriusXM radio. While the Model Y uses one central screen for everything, the ID.4’s dashboard makes it easy to find and use features without distraction.
Safety & Warranty
Volkswagen’s IQ.DRIVE safety system includes helpful tools like adaptive cruise control, lane assist, and emergency assist, keeping you safe on the road. The ID.4 is a 2024 IIHS TOP SAFETY PICK, showing it meets high safety standards. VW also includes two years of free maintenance, adding value to your ID.4. The Model Y doesn’t offer free maintenance, which could mean more costs over time.
Price & Value
With a starting price of $39,735, the ID.4 is more affordable than the Model Y. Potential federal tax credits make the ID.4 an even better deal. Its free charging and maintenance add up to even more savings, making the ID.4 a great choice for drivers who want an affordable electric SUV with lots of features. The Model Y costs more and lacks these perks, which makes the ID.4 a better value.Overall, the Volkswagen ID.4 is a fantastic choice for anyone looking for a comfortable, affordable, and easy-to-use electric SUV. It’s perfect for drivers who want a smooth, hassle-free EV without the high price tag.
Prices do not include additional fees and costs of closing, including government fees and taxes, any finance charges, service and handling fee of $129, or emissions testing fees. All prices, specifications, and availability subject to change without notice. Crain Volkswagen of Fayetteville retains all incentives. We’re sorry, availability of some equipment, options or features may be limited due to global supply issues affecting the auto industry. Please be sure to verify that the vehicle you purchase includes all expected features and equipment.